Usable memory less than installed!

[scherade]

@Fassou said in Usable memory less than installed!:

Use the CPU-Z to better show the two cases...

Salu2!

Ok, here they are with the CPU-Z

Salu2!

[Fassou]

@scherade Everything seems to indicate that at the hardware level everything is fine, and that it is the OS that is giving you the hassle, so leave all the modules plugged in as I understand it is a kit and they are all the same.

If you have not touched anything in msconfig, check anyway that you do not check the Max Memory box in Boot - Advanced Options. You can try activating it and putting 16384 and if it is still the same after restarting you go back in to deactivate it (it seems that this has worked for some).

If it does not work, open a CMD console in Administrator Mode and paste:

bcdedit /deletevalue {current} removememory bcdedit /deletevalue {current} truncatememory bcdedit /deletevalue {default} removememory bcdedit /deletevalue {default} truncatememory 

And then restart.

Salu2!

[scherade]

@Fassou said in Usable memory less than installed!:

bcdedit /deletevalue {current} removememory
bcdedit /deletevalue {current} truncatememory
bcdedit /deletevalue {default} removememory
bcdedit /deletevalue {default} truncatememory

I've tried both things but without result. When I put the code I got the error:

Error trying to delete the specified data element.
The element was not found.

Thanks anyway. Why can it give that error?

Best regards!

[Fassou]

Delete boot configuration lines, which could be causing the memory reservation failure.

If you can't find them, the problem isn't there.

If you have another disk, have you tried doing a clean install to see if it does it? Because the problem is that "something" is forcing that memory reservation, and on the networks you can find the most unusual stories of solving it by uninstalling some apps, ranging from boot managers to antivirus, which with the continuous update that W10 is, is fertile ground for this type of problem.

Then there are those who clean the contacts of some memory module and it is solved, but I suppose that is not your case.

Salu2!

[scherade]

@Fassou said in Usable memory less than installed!:

Delete boot configuration lines, which could be causing the memory reserve failure.

If you can't find them, the problem isn't there.

If you have another disk, have you tried doing a clean install to see if it does it? Because the problem is that "something" is forcing that memory reserve, and on the networks you can find the most unusual stories of solving it by uninstalling some apps, ranging from boot managers to antivirus, which with the continuous update that W10 is, is fertile ground for this type of problem.

Then there are those who clean the contacts of some memory module and it is solved, but I suppose that is not your case.

Salu2!

Thanks

Boot configuration lines? It sounds sophisticated to me... The fact is that the problem must come from the very beginning because when I put the 4 modules it doesn't start. It makes two attempts and starts again when the check shows "F9", then it loops and I have to restart manually, then Windows starts.

F9, I've looked in the motherboard manual and it says: <F9> Recovery capsule is not found.

It's an error code but I don't know what it means.

On the other hand I've seen this table, which I also don't know what it means but with the 4 modules it marks the speed that I reach with them.

It can be found here: https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/amd/ryzen_7/1700x

[Fassou]

@scherade said in Usable memory less than installed!:

The thing is that the problem must have been there from the beginning because when I put in the 4 modules it doesn't start. It makes two attempts and starts again when the check shows "F9", then it gets stuck in a loop and I have to manually restart it, then Windows starts up.

F9, I've looked in the motherboard manual and it says: <F9> Recovery capsule is not found.

Until now you hadn't mentioned that putting in the 4 modules it wouldn't start.

If the computer is giving you false starts and restarting several times before it can actually load the OS, there is a memory configuration problem.

Go into BIOS and load the default options, and try booting with them.

If it's no longer reserving 16GB, you've found the problem, and you can keep testing until you find the fastest memory configuration that allows you to use it without that limitation.

Perhaps that kit isn't designed for Ryzen.

Cheers!

PD: If your memory is this, it shows up as tested for Intel platform but not for AMD, so activating the XMP profile is likely to cause problems.

[scherade]

@Fassou

It has always given me boot problems with the 4 modules. No matter if I put the default options or not. It stutters with the 4 modules, what I don't understand is why 2 don't and 4 do... This kit is not for amd, it's for intel... I bought it because the ones that were for amd were very expensive and very scarce at the time. Looking for someone who said it worked with my configuration... and I bought them. They have the famous samsung b-die.

Thanks Fassou, Salu2!

[Fassou]

@scherade You'll have to play around with the timings by hand to get it to work, but success is not guaranteed.

Salu2!

[scherade]

@Fassou

Muchas gracias Fassou

I think I'm going to try a memory kit that the manufacturer says is fully compatible with my setup and if they work well I'll try to sell these I have, because I can't use them at 100% or so it seems. From G.skill they responded with this:

Please also understand that Ryzen platform does not natively support odd number CL timing (such as CL 15, 17, 19…etc) it will automatically adjust to the closest even number, this is why we did not include any odd CL timing memory kit into our AMD motherboard QVL.

[scherade]

@Fassou said in Usable memory less than installed!:

@scherade You'll have to play with the timings manually to get it to work, but success is not guaranteed.

Salu2!

Well, I think I've ruled out that it's a software problem for sure, correct me if I'm wrong... I've booted the PC with a USB with Hiren’s BootCD PE x64 (v1.0.2) and Windows recognizes the memory exactly the same.

Now I want to investigate if there may be one or more damaged modules because there's one in particular that can't be read with any program the specifications... neither with Windows nor with Thaiphoon Burner, cpu z,... none and I've tried many.

Is that already an indication that it's bad? Separately, I can get them all to work at 3200mhz, although the one I mentioned sometimes doesn't even start the PC.

Thanks and Salu2!

[scherade]

Well, in the end, after investigating here and there and with the help of the Thaiphoon Burner, I found the origin of the problem. There was a module with the perfect SPD and it was the one that worked without problems. In the rest, the SPDs were corrupt, or a part had been erased or it had been changed. The reason, I ignore it. The modules are now in Holland in an RMA to be restored. I would have done it myself, it doesn't have much mystery but I needed the paid version of the Thaiphoon and that came out more expensive than sending them to Holland. Because the cost of shipping had to be paid by me. G.Skill has a lifetime warranty.

Regards, Fassou

[Fassou]

@scherade Don't forget to let us know when everything is resolved, how was the RMA experience

Salu2!

[scherade]

@Fassou said in Usable memory less than installed!:

@scherade Don't forget to tell us when everything is resolved, how was the RMA experience

Salu2!

Of course. I'll tell you. From what I've read, it seems they don't work badly... we'll see.

Salu2!

[scherade]

@fassou said in Usable memory less than installed!:

@scherade Don't forget to tell us when everything is resolved, how was the RMA experience

Salu2!

I forgot to comment... until now. I did well with the RMA, almost a month without the memos. They sent me other modules, they didn't fix whatever was wrong with mine. These work as they should. The thing is that the heatsinks are ¿badly glued?, or at least not as before... They move with little effort... And they could come off very easily. In any case, I have them working without complaint.

Greetings and happy holidays.

[Clipper]

@scherade if it's any consolation some manufacturers are very "majos" I bought a patriot Viper black Manba ddr3, two modules of 8gs total 17 gs with XMC activated it works at 1866. When I bought an identical pack it only works at 1600.
According to the official patriot website it's normal... They don't guarantee that they will work if it's not a pack of 4/ 8 gs
Sends cojones...
Regards and Happy New Year